User Reviews (1 - 11 of 22)

Show these reviews first:

Highest Rated
Lowest Rated Newest
Oldest Most Helpful
Least Helpful

US Army Infantry all the way! Hoo-Ah!

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 16 / 29
Date: November 20, 2003
Author: Amazon User

Ever wanted that game that actually makes you feel like you're in the heat off a battle as a US Army Infantryman? Well this is the game to do it. You take control of different squads of infantryman (Rangers, Airborne, normal Infantry, etc.) as you send them through an urban area. Following the full ways of the United States Army (including Roles Of Engagement, Weapons, and Tactics) you must control the squad through their objective.

Much like the downloadable game "America's Army"[...] this game is made for the Army (or those interested in it.) Though most likely complicated and difficult, this game's graphics and gameplay are amazing. You can take control of the full chalk, a small squad (alpha or bravo) or just a single soldier. But remember if you do this, don't forget about the other team members. They're important to your mission.

A "HOO-AH" must-buy for those interested in the US Military or war games, but not for those who don't mind difficult missions.

Judge for yourself

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 7 / 8
Date: December 28, 2004
Author: Amazon User

I don't agree with these other critics. I'm a vietnam vet, and it's realistic enough for me. Who cares if you can't enter buildings, sewers, etc. - that's not the focus. Teamwork and solid tactics: moving from cover to cover, flanking, covering fire and timely use of smoke and grenades is what this game is all about. Don't look for a training sim for the army, it's a GAME. And don't look for another 1st person shooter, this is (finally!) something quite different. I've played all the best new generation war games: MOHAA, Vietcong, COD, Men of Valor, Pacific Assault. I think this definitely ranks with them, dismissed!

the best game for realistic war

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 4 / 5
Date: May 05, 2005
Author: Amazon User

this game is a new step for gaming.it makes it so u don't have to worry about who has the fastest reaction time and who can aim the best,its whose the better leader and better tactics.people who rate this so low is because they like to play the same ol type of games,thats it,this game makes it so u can't rambo ur way thru it.i highly recommend this to anyone who wants a realistic war expierence

frustrating no save game but fun

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 0 / 0
Date: May 01, 2006
Author: Amazon User

if you have played the conflict desert storm games, this game is along the same vein except you have two teams. the game is pretty much in the same part of the world. the most irritating thing about the game is you get no free saves whenever you want them. if you mess up you have to start the mission over. there are no medic packs lying around either as in the medal of honor games. the wounded have to be piggybacked to a medic. every move has to be planned. it's worth buying and playing.

Original and beautiful, but could have been much better

4 Rating: 4, Useful: 1 / 1
Date: October 05, 2004
Author: Amazon User

I haven't yet finished this game, but what I have seen is nothing short of stunning. That's too bad, because with a little more work this game could have been one of the greatest ever made.

Don't be fooled into thinking this game is a first person shooter with some aspects of tactical control. It's something much different. In FSW, you are an unseen squad leader, moving your two teams through a bombed-out, rubble-strewn, third-world hellhole liberally populated with AK-47 wielding fanatics. You cannot directly control any particular soldier in your squad. Instead, you give them commands, either as a team or individually. The game is essentially an exercise in observing an area for threats, moving one team into an overwatch position, bounding your other team forwards, observing for threats, etc.

Each team has a team leader with an M-4 carbine, an automatic rifleman with a M-249 SAW light machinegun, a grenadier with an M-16A2 rifle with an M-203 grenade launcher, and a rifleman with another M-4. Each squad also has fragmentation and smoke grenades at their disposal. At some points in the game you will have access to artillery fires and helicopter recon. If more than one of your men goes down the mission is a failure and you must restart from your last save point.

Enemy AI appears at first glance to be pretty poor, but this isn't always the case. Enemies are generally poor shots at longer ranges, but are deadly in close quarters. Usually, the best option is to use one team to engage the enemy from behind cover, while you flank around a building with the other. This will work about 85% of the time, but the enemy will sometimes trick you into moving into an ambush with your flanking team. The enemy will generally try to find cover and return fire on your troops. If they see one of their comrades go down, or are under fire from two different positions, the enemy tends to panic and rout, making them easy pickings. You often don't have to enagage an enemy, and it's rarely worth the effort unless you absolutely have to. It's often possible to bypass an enemy, or force him behind cover with suppressive fire and then break contact. The enemy also seems to have unlimited ammo, which is unfortunate becase they tend to simply blaze away at your troops, even when they're under cover. The enemy will not, however, shoot at your men if they can't see them. If you run into problems, you can usually break contact by throwing a smoke grenade between your men and the enemy. The notion of firing through the smoke never appears to have occurred to them.

Friendly AI is reasonably good. Your soldiers each have their own distinct voices and personality, ruunning the gamut from good-natured but stern leader, to cold-hearted killer, to irritating teenage soldier. Each soldier has subtle differences in his uniform, including using non-issue body armor or uniforms that are inapproprate for a desert/urban setting. Some of your noncommissioned officers even have combat patches (unit patches worn on the right shoulder). The junior elisted have a proclivity for whining and cussing, and the noncommissioned officers spend a great deal of time telling their charges to shut up and clean up their language. If your troops unexpectedly come under fire, it's not unusual for the entire team to start shouting obscenities!

For the greatest army ever fielded, though, your troops are pretty poor shots. Most kills happen only after you've flanked an enemy and he abandons his position. Also, if you're under fire and unsure of what to do, pressing the spacebar will cause your troops to hide behind the nearest available cover. Unfortunately, your troops have a nasty habit of hiding behind couches, wooden crates and other objects that tend to disintegrate quickly when exposed to liberal amounts of 7.62x39mm Soviet ammo. That, or your men will sometimes drop to the prone position in the middle of the steet, which tends to get them killed very quickly.

The graphics are nothing short of stunning, and the game does a great job of making each and every location unique. The level of detail, from advertisements on walls to rusted rebar sticking out of rubble, is like nothing I've ever seen before. It's really easy to lose focus on what you're doing by sightseeing.

You can only save as designated save points, usually immediately after completing an objective. This isn't as irritating as it might sound, though. The game has a replay function, which allows you to jump back into the action at any point. If half of Bavo Team just got cut down by a machine gunner, you can watch the replay, including of where the enemy is, come up with a better plan, rewind the replay to the point immediately before you entered his field of fire and try again. It's a great tool that allows you to observe your mistakes, and learn how to play better.

Unfortunately, the game is somewhat lacking. The enemy AI is entirely scripted. They generally stand around waiting for you to make contact, and are never aggressive. This game could have been much more interesting if you had to constantly watch your six for irregulars stalking you, or if you had to suddenly take fire as a squad of the enemy tries to overrun your own squad. Alas, I have yet to run accross any situation of this nature.

Additionally, there game tends to be fairly linear. While you can bypass many enemies on the way to your objective, there is typically only one way to actually assault the stupid thing. Many enemies are smart enough to position themselves on likely avenues of approach, and there is typically just one way to flank them. Since they're also scripted, the replay value tends to be low. Once you've beaten a mission, there's really no reason go back and try it again.

Movements are also limited. Your troops generally sprint from cover to cover, though they sometimes walk. I often found myself wishing I could have them low-crawl behind cover or kick in doors so that I could take cover in a building. Also, you men all appear to have medical waivers for their knees, because they refuse to climb or jump. I can't count the number of times I fought my way down an alley, only to be stymied by...a five foot wall! In the real world, a soldier would climb over the stupid thing and carry on with his mission. In this game, you have to turn around and find another way.

To conclude, this game is nothing short of revolutionary, but it could have been better. Some games, like Half-Life, define a genre. Others, like Doom, create them. This game is the latter. For all it's beauty and originality, it's still a rough-cut, a work in progress. Hopefully, expansion packs or sequels will address the problems with AI and scripting. But if you're in the mood for something different, then you could do a lot worse than Full Spectrum Warrior.

I'd give this game a 3.5/5 rating, but since Amazon doesn't work that way, I'll round it up to a 4/5. It's really, really good...but not great.

Decent Game, Just Gotta Get a Hang Of It

4 Rating: 4, Useful: 0 / 1
Date: July 30, 2007
Author: Amazon User

If you read the other reviews everyone complains about how it's to complicated or not realistic or the save system isn't good or the resupply system is bad. Well in some respects it is, as far as a video game goes. But this game is based on a REAL program used by the US Army. So of course it's not going to be easy, commanding a sqaud is never easy. And being resupplied during a mission is almost never going to happen. So yes this is realistic in some respects. In others it's not. Your teammates don't fire on targets unless you tell them, sometimes even when they're being fired open in the open. You have to tell them to set up fire zones or killzones in order for them to do their best. Basically all you have to do is pay attention which it seems like no one on here does. Check your corners, advance from cover with caution, always set up firezones when you have one sqaud advance and then have the other sqaud set up their zone while the other sqaud advances toward them. It's slow paced but if don't go slow then you die plain and simple. So yes it is a good game, and for the listed price it's worth it. It's only frustrating if you run and gun, which in life you can't do. And realism is what the game is going for. So if you don't like almost absolute realism then you won't like this game.

Great!!!

4 Rating: 4, Useful: 1 / 8
Date: September 19, 2004
Author: Amazon User

One of the reviews said that the game has not been released yet, which is hasn't but the demo has been put out on the web for download... so...

The demo is extremely fun even though all it contains is the Training and 1 mission. If you are not sure about this game I suggest your download the demo, as with all games.

If there is no demo (DOOM 3 & Battlefield: Vietnam) then wait for your friends to buy it so you can try it out without wasting your money!! haha

Easy game but frustrated installation

4 Rating: 4, Useful: 1 / 6
Date: September 27, 2004
Author: Amazon User

First of all, this game is lacking of some challenge mission. It seems look like hard to play but after you master the move, the game play is so boring. The installation is frustrated. It required direct X 9.0c. Where is the CD-key? I couldn't find it. I looked around the menue, cd disc, cd case, box, etc and I did not see any cd-key for entering to continue the installation. It had no hint or mention where to find the cd-key. Gee! finally, I found it behind the disc # 3 on the cd case. you have to take the cd disc # 3 out and the cd-key is printed on the cd case. After the installation, my computer crashed twice during the gameplay but it is ok now. I did not know what happened. You have to take the training course before you started the mission because you will never understand what the maneu talking about. Actually, you can put the maneu into the trash can. After you mastering the move. The game is so boring without any challenge. You can easy order your firing team to kill the enemies. Well, this game only worth 4 stars because the pretty graphic, that's it!

Yeeeeeee-Haaaaaaa <Gulp>

4 Rating: 4, Useful: 2 / 6
Date: October 05, 2004
Author: Amazon User

Well, where to begin......

I`ve been waiting a while for this title to come out. I`d seen it running on the console and was hoping that it would be at least as good.

Graphics
I must say that for the most part the graphics and effects are outstanding. The squad members look good and the terrain is well done. They`ve done a good job with combining an atmospheric setting with appropriate music to give the game a great feel. There are some lovely effects when one of your team gets injured and the action slows down to see blood spilling from an entry wound as he gets blown off his feet. Sometimes you even get a blood splash as if onto the screen to make you feel even more involved. Now and again something strange will happen such as one of your men being hit in the leg by small-arms fire and flipping 30ft (I`m not exaggerating) into the air! Generally though it`s all well done. The many cut scenes are exceptional.

Gameplay
Well thought out and put together. The AI for your squads and the bots are pretty much spot on. It does have a console feel about the game which is a shame in my book as on occasion it can make things look a bit too `arcadey`. The missions do differ a fair bit, although you get the distinct feeling of being led around by the hand. Basically you just follow the waypoint markers with little choice in doing anything else. This can be quite a downer as having more freedom to choose the routes you took etc would add to the replayability aspect of the game.

Audio
As previously mentioned the sound is good. The music is fitting and the sound effects are well done. There`s a fair amount of chatter between your squad members which will let you know how they`re feeling about the present situation. There`s A LOT of swearing so parents be warned.

The Downside
Personally the only things that really made me cringe was the seriously over zealous pro-USA feel to the game. I just couldn`t help but laugh when one of my squad piped up something along the lines of `Who do they think they are messin with... we`re the USA!` This is where all sense of realism leaves the game (Or maybe US troops really talk like that!). There are many entries in the game manual commenting how you`ll be operating with the best trained soldiers in the World and how `US soldiers don`t become rattled under fire` The manual is worth reading purely on the hilarity of such comments.

Overall
A great game. The terrible BS given in the manual and gung-ho comments made in game don`t really spoil things. I`m sure the American audience laps it up and probably believes it, but the rest of the World knows better 8-)

A good attempt that falls very short of the mark!

2 Rating: 2, Useful: 10 / 11
Date: October 28, 2004
Author: Amazon User

Basically, this is a game that wraps multiple types of game play into one package. That is where this game went wrong. Also, some of the "HIGH" ratings were kids or people that reviewed this game based on the DEMO!!! You cannot truly rate a game unless you have played through the whole thing. THAT IS HOW THE GAMING MAGAZINES DO IT!!!

Any designer, manufacturer, builder knows that it is almost impossible to make an effective "ALL-IN-ONE" device because it usually does some things very well and some things fairly well or poorly.

In this game, you play from the 3rd person perspective, more like you hover over your currently active squad. You command your teams of soldiers with mouse clicks and key commands while receiving orders from an off-site commander.

Now this is unique! However, this is what stinks! You feel like your watching the action more than participating. You also have to wrestle with hard to observe terrain, angles, camera views and if you make a mistake, you cannot quickly respond. Ouch! Oh, did I mention that the game has designated save points? Yep! So if you blow it, you must go back to the last save point and start again. This is not horrible, but not pleasant either.

The good parts are that this game really requires you to think, use strategy, be patient, it is unique, there are some excellent tutorials (about 30-40 minutes worth) to help you learn the skills you'll need to get started, and the game brings in outside support like helicopter recon, mortar/artillery support, Armored Bradley vehicles. This game also offers Co-Op play which is a nice addition. I do like the hardcore cursing in this game (M****rF****r is one shining example) because I am an adult and I want adult level, realistic games. Kids don't need to play every game ok? That is what the ESRB ratings system is for. So I say thank you to the developers for doing it! You will not find ammo, health paks, aliens, space stations, rocket cars, jet packs, or secret weapons laying around or on the dead bodies or behind hidden walls. If you run out of ammo, your stuck!

The bad parts are complicated camera angles, buggy response to your commands at times, the game is a bit of a hog on resources, the action is not that exciting, the visuals are not bad but not great, there is a lot of unnecessary HARDCORE cursing(I LOVE it but any parent with a kid under 18 probably will not !!) This game is VERY short too! Just as your skills are starting to get good, the game is over!

Who is this game good for? -
If you like RTS(real time strategy) games but wish you could get more deeply immersed in them...this game will excite you. I doubt this will appeal to 1st person shooter fans that don't like RTS games.

Overall, I appreciate it for it's uniqueness. Yet, I also found it very unsatisfying. Due to the lack of excitement, poor camera angles, slow, clumsy response of your soldiers, mediocre AI for the enemies and buggy action...I cannot recommend this game.

I will make a prediction though - I bet that another company will make a similar game only better or there will be a FSW 2 and the developers will have tweaked it into a lean, mean, shoot'em up game by learning from their mistakes. For the present - I would not bother with this game.

Review Page: 1 2 3 Next 

Actions