User Reviews (1 - 11 of 47)

Show these reviews first:

Highest Rated
Lowest Rated Newest
Oldest Most Helpful
Least Helpful

what's next this was whack

1 Rating: 1, Useful: 0 / 0
Date: May 11, 2008
Author: Amazon User

This ruined sonic completely the storyline is whack the 2player mode sucks and kinda hard the way the you run and there's a space or a part you get stuck in, the old sonic games were more better with better storyline and design this game was a little off balance, so this game was'nt good at all.

It's broken.

1 Rating: 1, Useful: 0 / 0
Date: March 28, 2008
Author: Amazon User

This is, unfortunately, a bastardization of the entire Sonic franchise.

When I bought this, it came in a box that said "Platinum Family Favorites". Trouble with that is it *still* hasn't grossed over a million sales, even if you combine the 360 version's sales with the PS3 version's sales and look at it globally. It's in the 700,000 range.

Enough boring stuff, here's the kicker: It's broken. This is not a finalized game. And the fact Sega can release a patch any time they fixed something but hasn't done so at all is incredibly disturbing.

This was the first Sonic game I've ever played on any console that I've had a game over on the first level where none of the deaths were my fault. I've gone through solid objects, bounced off of objects and fell and gone the wrong way only (unintentionally) to get a time over.

What seriously irks me is that this game uses the same physics engine that Super Smash Bros. Brawl uses (the Havok engine). This was not in debugging long enough to warrant this as the final game. A beta version, yes, but not the final game. Sega has done much better with Sonic and the Secret Rings than this game, because Secret Rings is actually playable.

Recommended for: NOBODY

Sonic the Fan Game

2 Rating: 2, Useful: 0 / 0
Date: March 27, 2008
Author: Amazon User

This game is awful, it was rushed through and through. The bugs and load times really derail this game. Not even sonic can save this game, it's a down right abomination.

So why do I like this game? I don't know. This is a game I play for about 20 minutes, then eject it in disgust. Then the next day... for some reason, I pop it back in.

This game is confused of itself, trying to do too many things at once, and not really shining in any of them.

Take the adventure levels for example, these probably made a return because of Sega's "retracing" of why Sonic was so good. They saw that people liked Sonic Adventure and tried to mimick it. Unfortunately, the adventure fields were NOT what made Sonic adventure great.

What does stand out in this game is the Idea, the fact that this game COULD have been one of the greatest games of all time, and that in itself is a reason to own this game.

Also, the character models are incredible, the characters and SOME levels look stunning, especially the pre-rendered cutscenes. The music in this game is a different story, there are some really memorable pieces, and then there are the crappy ones that bring down the whole experiance.

Loading times! here we go. The load times are a monumental kick in the groin in this game. The loading scripts were obviously thrown together at the last minute. What I think happened in developement is this; They created a Universal load script that constantly loads and drops files from memory, regardless of what it's loading next or what it's already loaded. So each load screen, it has dropped everything from memory, and loads everything from scratch. There are major displays of this throughout the game.

So in closing, if you are a fan of Sonic, this game is definetly worth the price, although I do admit, randomly running around town is much more fun than any of the levels. If you don't know who Sonic is, or just looking for a good game, then pass on this one, I have no idea why I love this game so much.

Worst Sonic 3D Game Ever Made in the History of the Sonic Franchise

1 Rating: 1, Useful: 1 / 1
Date: January 16, 2008
Author: Amazon User

I played and beat this game. There is almost absolutely nothing good about this game at all. The absolutely most terrible thing in the game IS!: the camera. Sonic 3D adventure games have gotten a pretty good, uhm, how do I say? Expectation from fans to always have bad cameras. But this one jumps over those freaking expectations with a trampoline and jet pack. It's the worst one in ANY Sonic game in general. I tried flying out a window with Tails, as you had to in order to float to the next building and grab a Chaos Emerald, but the camera decided to have a game of musical chairs with me and so I ran out of flight time and perished.

The game is ludicrously difficult. If it wasn't for the bad camera, half of the game's difficulty would instantly be gone. Almost every time an enemy killed me, or I fell down a classic bottomless pit hole, it was because of the stupid camera. However, the hardest parts in the game are the levels where Sonic must run at his maximum speed to overcome some short-time obstacle and these aren't hard because of the camera. No, these are just hard from bad design; it's the hardest aspect of the game. Some of these levels could have been done in literally one or two minutes, oh, except for the fact it's stupidly easy to die during these. You can't break, you can't even slow down and bumping into absolutely anything results in death. Ironically, the very final boss in the game is easy as dirt in comparison to the rest of the game, it was pretty anti-climatic.

However, despite that, the game does have a couple things I strongly admire. Mainly, Sonic and Shadow now have differences and aren't 100% clones of each other. Shadow's Homing Attack performs slower than Sonic's, but Shadow also jumps higher. He also has the ability to, after doing a homing attack, unleash a frenzy of punches and kicks mid-air.

The music is also excellent. Seriously, listen to the track "Flame Core - Volcano". That's the only example you need. However, it seems Crush 40 did very little music, if any, for the game, which disappoints me. I believe all they did was a remix of some song from Shadow the Hedgehog.

As well, the graphics are pretty great for it, too! The best example of the game's graphics is Dr. Robotnik. They really put a lot of detail on his face with his mustache, chubbiness and even blue veins being visible under his skin (but not disgustingly bulging out, it was very well done).

Also, this is the only Sonic game I know of where Sonic actually dies. Sure, they bring him back by getting all seven Dragon Bal-I mean Chaos Emeralds and making a wish to bring him back, but still! He freakin' dies!

It had the potential to be a really great game, because this game legitimately had some good ideas not used in previous games, but it failed massively, entirely due to the camera and the unbalanced difficulty.

The most criminly underrated game out there!

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 2 / 6
Date: December 31, 2007
Author: Amazon User

This game rocks. to bad so many people hate it. I mean it's definently not perfect because all games have there flaws (especilly Super Mario Bros..) I would of liked it if Sonic Next-Gen (A.K.A Sonic the Hedgehog) (A.K.A. Sonic '06) isn't on the Wii. then I'd have more fun with it.

LAWLZ

1 Rating: 1, Useful: 1 / 4
Date: December 12, 2007
Author: Amazon User

This. is. the. worst. game. ever. handsdown

if you like this.. youre under 10 years old, or you have a mental handicap.
this game promotes beastiality with the relationship of sonic and a human. as well as lacks any fun or gameplay.

+ the camera is horrible.

why sega, why?

Good game

4 Rating: 4, Useful: 0 / 2
Date: December 08, 2007
Author: Amazon User

This was an effort from Sega, atleast they are trying. I have no complaints about story, its just the gameplay was a bit buggy. Once you can get use to the controls the game is pretty fun. Silver is an interesting new character.

Worst Sonic Game Ever

2 Rating: 2, Useful: 2 / 3
Date: November 26, 2007
Author: Amazon User

I saw this game on demo in Best Buy last year just before I bought my Xbox 360. Considering I loved the Dreamcast version so much when they made it in 3D and I've enjoyed several of the Sonic games on my daughter's Gamecube, I was excited about this game and told my wife I wanted it for Christmas (Between Call of Duty 3 and Sonic I would buy whichever one she didn't get for me). How can you not like Sonic?

Imagine my disappointment once I started playing this game. Wow. I had no idea it was going to be this bad. The game looks great and plays fast but that's about all. Just about everything else is wrong and Sonic Team should be ashamed of themselves for putting out such an inferior product. Giving this game 2 stars is generous, but I won't give it one star because it is fun in short spurts and could've been so much better... so much potential gone to waste. By far the most annoying thing about this game is all the cheap deaths from bad camera angles... you just can't see where you're going far too often and that's just unacceptable. Combine that with the limited save opportunities where you most assuredly WILL run out of lives and the game is unnecessarily difficult. Not even difficult in a rewarding way, like Ninja Gaiden... difficult in a cheap, frustrating way.

It was hard to do and I really didn't want to give up on this game but I ended up selling it to Gamestop not too long ago for whatever they'd give me. Lesson learned: check reviews before buying, which I did not, I banked on it being good. Whoops. That was 50 bucks my wife could've spent on something else.

Unless you are a die-hard Sonic fan AVOID THIS GAME at all costs. If you are a die-hard then be very careful, I would definitely suggest renting this first because I honestly don't believe it's worthy of inclusion in the Sonic series.

I would rate zero stars if possible!

1 Rating: 1, Useful: 1 / 2
Date: November 05, 2007
Author: Amazon User

My wife actually got motion sickness from this game and had to run to the bathroom. I play a lot of FPSs with all kinds of action and motion and this game gave me a headache in less than 10 minutes. Camera angles are terrible. How did Sega say "Yeah, nice work team, lets go to production." Somebody should be fired for that decision.

Not the good old Sonic!

1 Rating: 1, Useful: 3 / 4
Date: June 22, 2007
Author: Amazon User

I was a huge Sonic fan back when I had a Genesis. I havent played much Sonic in between, but I have a Xbox 360 and thought this game would be fun and nostalgic. The graphics are great and the cut scenes are entertaining, but overall this game is a huge dissapointment. I found myself frustrated and angry to say the least at the lack of save options, glitchy gameplay and unbearable load times. Repeating entire stretches of levels over and over becuase I cant save after one level- I have to wait until I complete 3! Well that just sucks the fun out of it. I think I need anger management classes after playing this. I've found plenty of challenging and entertaining videogames for my 360, and this is NOT one of them!

Review Page: 1 2 3 4 5 Next 

Actions