User Reviews (1 - 11 of 21)

Show these reviews first:

Highest Rated
Lowest Rated Newest
Oldest Most Helpful
Least Helpful

Scorched Earth PG III Rocks

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 21 / 21
Date: October 13, 2000
Author: Amazon User

I've played the other PGs before but this one is really outstanding. The 3D really has made the genre visually beautiful and more tactically relevant. Also, with the new format of taking different missions throughout the campaigns, no two campaigns are alike. Its fun to actually have a war game (I've played many) that tries to follow the historical battles/engagements of the Eastern front. One of the best touches is seeing how the experience of the Russians initially starts off poor and increases likewise with equipment. The only thing I miss from the original PG is having German or Russian audios of orders being given for various operations. This game engages one both on the levels of being fun and intellectually challenging. This is an outstanding game.

Good old PG....but beautiful!

4 Rating: 4, Useful: 38 / 38
Date: October 14, 2000
Author: Amazon User

PG III: Scorched Earth is the latest addition in a long series of turnbased strategy games. I have found the other games in this series very addictive and I find they strike a fine balance between depth and almost instant playability. That is to say, these games are not for hardcore wargamers but for people who love tanks and boardgames but don't want to micromanage too much. Compared to Peoples General and Panzer general II, this game has outstanding graphics. It is really nice to see your Tiger tank race down a road, beautifully rendered, to meet its adversary. The sound effects match very well, adding to the immersive effect without standing very much out. This also means at least I haven't found them to be annoying.

On the army management side PG III has expanded the leader side, actually putting faces on them and giving you a leader roster to choose from to command your new units. The units themselves don't gain experience but the leader does and as he becomes promoted his unit can perform more actions per turn. This is really powerful and lends more flexibility to your units. Your fighter plane can move twice, for instance looking for an enemy bomber, shoot and move again.

The missions are more varied than the ones previously encountered in this series. You will be required to fight breakout battles, search and destroy missions, as well as the good old take certain objectives. Having only just bought the game I won't comment on the campaign design but it is in general a pretty simple game to learn and I feel that it adds plenty of new sides to satisfy veteran players of the series.

Great Game!

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 55 / 58
Date: October 15, 2000
Author: Amazon User

Being a fan of the Panzer General series of games, I really enjoyed this latest enstallment. It builds on the existing game system greatly with new features with a new way of aquiring your army and promotions. The Video and unit artwork is a lot better. The new leader specials, awards and promotion system is great. It really gave you a better feeling of what it was like to use the many unique weapons systems of the day, all the way from a Panzer II to the King Tiger, and all other systems as well. It handles, finally, the dreaded German 88 in such a way that you really realize it's terror. The game also has a battle generator so you can make your own battles as well as online gaming. The game did occationally drop me to system, but these errors only occured seldom. Save games were good and I had no problems there. Video and animations of the units was very good with no problems. To me this is by far the best war game I have played, and I have played them all since the early 1980's. It has great replayablity as well. So far I have played about 10 campaigns. Just to do one took about 30 hours. I could have done it quicker but it was too great to rush through. And unlike the old Panzer Generals, there seem to be much larger campaigns and more scenarios.

Great Strategy Game

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 7 / 8
Date: December 04, 2000
Author: Amazon User

Panzer General III displays a battlefield that will put you in the mood to form serious strategies. The game is not overly complicated but you soon learn that what seems to be the most straightforward plan of attack will not always work! It gets you to think. Decent sound effects, good unit movement, nice display.

Not worth the price!

3 Rating: 3, Useful: 1 / 9
Date: January 02, 2001
Author: Amazon User

The game is full of strategy which is fun. The game is geared toward experienced players. This is not a game for kids younger than 15-16yrs. due to the complicated aspects of the game. I found glitches in the C.D. which frustrates the player.

Looks a lot like 3D Assault

3 Rating: 3, Useful: 1 / 18
Date: January 04, 2001
Author: Amazon User

I don't own this game, but just from looking at the screenshots I can tell that it looks exactly like Panzer General 3D Assault, which I do own.

More of The Same But It Was Good To Begin With

4 Rating: 4, Useful: 19 / 19
Date: January 05, 2001
Author: Amazon User

The new PG adds very little to the previous version, other than changing the interface. At the same time I have always enjoyed PG so I value this new edition mostly for the new scenarios and campaigns. For me a campaign pack would have done the same job. As a gamer who sticks to the same old games over the years I was glad to see this one. For someone familiar with the previous version and looking for variety this will be a disappointment.

For someone new to PG this will be as good a start as any of the other versions. The game generally takes a while to figure out and can be quite frustrating at first as your army tends to get beaten up all the time. As you gain experience with the game you will find it more and more enjoyable not just as tactical combat but I think you can also appreciate the oveeral campaign strategy of building an army of experienced and complimentary units.

Among the few new things the most important is probably removing the prestige as the "currency" of the game and making acquisition of new units conditional on their availability. As a result you no longer end up with a clearly overpowering force in the later stages of the campaigns as usually happened with PG II.

The other important change is that units do not get experience through battles but instead rely on promotions for the commander assigned. This really put an end to the common strategy of having units fight tough battles in the beginning just to upgrade their experience.

Overall, the game is like a picture from an old vacation - you like to look at it for the memory but it doesn't generate any new excitement.

jah volt herr general!

4 Rating: 4, Useful: 5 / 9
Date: March 08, 2001
Author: Amazon User

This was my first PG video game, but about my eigth that I have been searching for to quell my desire to be a general and use my brains to do something similar to what they did in WW2. PG does that! I find it fairly accurate and a lot of fun. What could have been done to make it more challenging, fun and realistic would be to take into account supply and logistics. Guderion, nor Karhkov, could just click a mouse and wait a turn to be completely refitted! Maybe the next PG, PG4, they will! docv

Addictive stuff

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 7 / 7
Date: May 01, 2001
Author: Amazon User

Panzer General III is a further refinement of Panzer General II with excellent 3D graphics. This Scorched Earth package concentrates on the Russian Front.

The game play is similar to that of Panzer General II and with the option of playing set senarios or campaigns or generate your own battle. Settings can be altered to suit your own abilities or preferences to make the game more easy to handle or to make more challenging. Presitage points are no longer used to obtain new units, instead allotted slots are avaiable to build up your army.

Panzer General III is basically a progression of previous Panzer General games and are very enjoyable and addictive to play.

One thing that would be nice to see if it could be done is to have a campaign generater.

Great New Panzer General Title!!!

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 11 / 12
Date: May 21, 2001
Author: Amazon User

If you enjoyed earlier titles in this series BUY IT! If you've never played a PG title before, but have an interest in WWII or strategy games--give this title a try. Ownership of earlier titles is unecessary to play or enjoy the game. It provides a simulation of WWII tactical warfare on the eastern front. The game places you as the commander of German or Russian armies: You select your commanders, equipment and the strategy. The game is highly addictive and the graphics & sound effects draw you into the game. You will tremble when a royal tiger rumbles over the hill in front of you(complete with the squeal of late-war German armor)!

PGII was a quantum leap forward in graphics/sound, user interface, and gameplay mechanics over the original PG. PGIII is an equally large improvement over PGII. It provides great graphics/sound and most of all brings greater balance & refinement to the game. Being a fan of earlier versions, I was initially disappointed at the apparent elimination of the Prestige Point system. However, after learning to play the game I realized that the prestige points are still there, they just are no longer used a bank account as in earlier versions of PG. Your leaders, available promotions, available equipment and roster slots are all based upon your prestige and success on the battlefield.

Although you will amass slightly smaller armies, this is actually an improvement: It allows you to concentrate on your individual units more and makes them more important. Mulitple moves,attacks and special abilities based on leader experience levels balance the reduced numbers and are part of the evolution of PG to a more sophisticated and balanced game.

In earlier versions of PG your armies snowballed from early successes enabling your armies to roll over your opponents with minimal effort. PGIII is more balanced and makes you sweat until the final objective of your campaign is completed. You also never run out of enemies: In PGII I frequently eliminated all opposing forces from the battlefield; in PGIII the enemy keeps coming at you until you complete your objective (which varies depending on the scenario).

In a word: AWESOME! I can't wait for Pacific General III & PG IV!

Review Page: 1 2 3 Next 

Actions