User Reviews (1 - 11 of 22)

Show these reviews first:

Highest Rated
Lowest Rated Newest
Oldest Most Helpful
Least Helpful

why?!?

1 Rating: 1, Useful: 8 / 13
Date: October 20, 2003
Author: Amazon User

Oh my gosh, we are so disappointed in this game. My sons and I love playing the previous Commandos games, but we have nice, large monitors, and never play a game at anything less than 1024x768 (up to 1600x1200, where the game allows). And we love playing coop mode in several games (these, Ghost Recon, Civ 3, etc).

However, for unfathomable reasons, Eidos has taken three incredible non-user friendly actions with this game:
(1) removed mappable hotkeys
(2) restricted resolution to 800x600 (nuts)
(3) removed coop mode (incomprehensible)

Yes, they added other coop modes, which is great, but WHY remove coop mode? Other games provide coop AND other mp modes.

And 800x600? Please. Very few people play at that low resolution anymore. Polls show that the most common game resolutions now played are 1280x960/1024 and 1024x768.

And no mappable hotkeys?

I wonder where these games are being developed, and who the software architects are, because these actions are inexcusable in this day of good design patterns.

I very much appreciate the reviews here and elsewhere. The two games we most wanted last Christmas, then in the Spring, then later, were Commandos 3 and the new Tomb Raider game. Reviews informed us of the TR debacle before we experienced that disappointment, and fortunately, I'm able to return this lousy game and get my money back.

Don't get me wrong. I *want* this game to be good. If Eidos puts some effort into allowing a useful resolution and restores coop mode, I'll gladly plug my nickel down again. But I let my money speak, and right now it's saying, "Nope."

Not Recommended

1 Rating: 1, Useful: 4 / 4
Date: November 04, 2003
Author: Amazon User

I read all the reviews, and after playing this game I can't be more agreed. This game is absolutely not recommended and a big turn down to all commandos fans everywhere.

Pure trash

1 Rating: 1, Useful: 6 / 8
Date: October 27, 2004
Author: Amazon User

Avoid at all costs. This game is pure trash, it has none of great story, diverse characters and involved thinking that put Commandos 1 & 2 among the best strategy games ever written. C3 has better graphics, equal music and NOTHING else. Controls are bad - the lack of weapon shortcuts make this game almost unplayable. There are no cutscenes between missions and most missions play out in a few locations. Gone are all the nice details from C2, like furniture items; you cannot hide in cupboards and you cannot hide bodies anymore.

Pyro would have done a better job had they just made some new maps for C2 and released that instead of this cr*p.

Not worth it

1 Rating: 1, Useful: 3 / 4
Date: April 16, 2004
Author: Amazon User

I love commando 1 and 2 alot. I played commando 2 for more than a year and still love to play it with hardest and still beat the game with no alarm from the enermy. I install the commando 3 then I don't feel like to play it after the tutorial.
The control of the game is so bad that I don't wan't to lean and play the game. I wait until the expansion if any, and if they fixed then I will play. Otherwise, I won't play it and their rate from me will be less than a star.

not even worth one star!!!

1 Rating: 1, Useful: 1 / 3
Date: November 13, 2003
Author: Amazon User

Too bad, the graphics, I see more squares, missions are designed like cheating customers,ie, too simple, too few, they are ruining the good name of commando series, STOP THIS CRIME!!!!!!!!!!

Crap

1 Rating: 1, Useful: 0 / 5
Date: December 09, 2005
Author: Amazon User

I bought the game yesterday. During the last 24 hours I've been trying to get past the tutorial. It is impossible. There is no way to change the difficulty setting. The mission objectives make no sense at all (If they are commandos, why do they have to kill every single German they encounter) and the computer will throw hordes of enemies that seem to have just teleported from the Enterprise as more than 400 have already come out of a small wagon and they keep coming every extact 8 seconds.

Altough the graphics are nice (I wish I could zoom more, tough) I did not pay this amount of money for 1 mission.

I strongly advice you to download the demo and see for yourself if this game is for you before you buy it.

I replayed Commandos 2 as an antidote to this disappointment

2 Rating: 2, Useful: 6 / 6
Date: April 16, 2004
Author: Amazon User

Like most, I agree that Commandos 3 is no where near as good as its predecessor.

In terms of game play, the levels are less challenging, requiring far less strategy and nuance (you can go in gung-ho and kill everyone easily, unlike C2 which punished such impatience). I was disappointed at the lack of levels and the speed with which this game could be completed. The controls are no where near as easy to master or as intuitive as C2 was, plus key (and fun) characters, tools, weapons and techniques are missing from this edition.

In terms of overall presentation, C3 lacks the intros and cut scenes of C2, which, although not essential to the game, did add some appeal. Most disturbingly however where the sheer number of bugs in the game. I did eventually download the patch which fixed some of the issues (though not really to my satisfaction), but for a game of this calibre and one so anxiously anticipated by gamers across the world, so many bugs is unacceptable. There is nothing more frustrating than having to constantly reload your profile because the game has crashed and deleted your save-games. Grrr.

Overall, a very disappointing experience - not worth the money to buy it new and well worth an email to the makers to voice your disappoitment.

What a Let Down

2 Rating: 2, Useful: 4 / 4
Date: October 31, 2003
Author: Amazon User

I've had great expectations for this game. I have played the first two parts, and I call myself a big fan of Commandos series. Playing this game makes me feel as if the developers have created the third part before the second one. Graphics are pretty much the same, if not inferior to part two, and the environment is much less interactive. Now you can examine only other soldiers and boxes, whereas you could examine almost every object in part two. Range of weapons is too short now. I entered a room and I could not shoot the enemy standing at the other side, except with a rifle. The range of the hand gun and the machine gun simple couldn't reach him, which is totally silly. Help screen of the game says that all of the commandos can use gas grenade, but in fact only the Sapper can. Little things like that have greatly contributed to my disappointment. I miss the Driver too. AI is somewhat improved and the game is more difficult, which is good since the only objection I had to part two is that it was a bit too easy. Other changes have ruined the game for me. Can't help feeling that the developer was awfully sluggish and uninventive this time around. I wish they had released an expansion pack with few minor improvements for Commandos 2 Men of Courage in stead of this disaster.
If I hadn't played the first two parts, this game might have gotten more than two stars, but as it is maybe two stars is too generous.
Harshly yours,
Aster.

Disappointment Plus

2 Rating: 2, Useful: 3 / 3
Date: November 02, 2003
Author: Amazon User

After thoroughly enjoying Commandos 2, I looked forward with great anticipation to Commandos 3 only to be greatly disappointed. The characters and graphics are basically the same but the actual play is quite different.There are no varying levels of play so it seems everyone is playing at expert level which can make the game for average gamers very difficult and frustrating. The actual keyboard selections for actions seem more complicated and the loss of time in selecting the proper action often results in the gamer getting killed off and the game having to be re-loaded adding to one's frustration. The only positive I see in this game is any satisfaction the gamer might get in completing a mission. They all seem too difficult for the average gamer of which I am. The cost of the game is higher than the satisfaction received. I could not recommend it.

A decent game.

3 Rating: 3, Useful: 13 / 16
Date: May 21, 2004
Author: Amazon User

I really enjoyed this game to a point. Having played the other 3 Commandos games, I could not wait for this to come out. The graphics are better than the other games even when you zoom in. The other games got pixelly where as this one doesn't. If it does, it's time to upgrade (I played this on a pentium 4, 512 meg ram, 128 meg video card).

What I liked was the graphics, how challenging the game was, and the way the landscape changed making you change your strategy.

What I didn't like was the controls, no cutscenes leading up to the next level, and there wasn't alot of strategy involved beyond what I already metioned. There are no more hot keys to control which weapon you use and other funtions. that really hurts this game more than anything. The cutscenes and other "eye candy" things I can do without (though I really enjoy them), but the based on the other 3 games, the stratgey involved stinks. Not more sneak attacks or thinking before you act. You can go in guns blazing and not suffer like the other games.

I did enjoy the game, but with the controls and strategy they took with this game, it really hurt the game. This could have and should have been an awesome game. But all we are left with is an average game with a few really good levels. At this price (and probably lower would be better), I would recommend this game, especially to people who have played the Commando series. But definitely don't pay full price.

Review Page: 1 2 3 Next 

Actions