User Reviews (1 - 5 of 5)

Show these reviews first:

Highest Rated
Lowest Rated Newest
Oldest Most Helpful
Least Helpful

Most fun aerial combat sim yet

4 Rating: 4, Useful: 6 / 7
Date: May 12, 2003
Author: Amazon User

Since the dawn of computers with graphics cards, WWI combat games have been a favorite genre with few standouts. "Red Ace Squadron" (RAS), an early entry in the recent revival of this style, achieves what few others do: riveting and enjoyable gameplay without the complexity of either flight simulators or the lengthy and involved "plot" scenarios that are darlings of game magazines and no one else.

The designers of this game realized the task was play, and thus hybridized flying games with flight simulators to produce what might be called a flight combat toy, meaning that it represents reality instead of trying to duplicate it so that users can quickly get into the game and begin enjoying WWI-style aerial combat.

It recreates the fun and strategy of flying without representing the true complexity of an airplane, reaching a new height of playability. Fly with a joystick, or keyboard, or as most do keyboard and mouse, and control will be intuitive. Your missions appear on intro screens in abrupt phrases like "Defend base" and "Destroy tanks," but the translation of this to gameplay requires more tactical precision than one might think.

Maneuvering is the most immediate fun for the user, since once airborne one handles a plane that reacts like a barnstorming psychopath is driving. Pull rolls and take a steep dive - you'll be able to turn away from earth in time. Your plane isn't "fast" in the sense of breathtaking speed of screen display, but events happen quickly enough that the pacing will seem appropriate. In the same way that the designers were realistic about the market for a flying game, they are realistic about missions and make them basic exercises which get complex in their own ways.

The architects of adventure in each of the ten levels in two difficulty modes, through a desire to provide a distinctive type of narrative in each level, give each a basic story: rescue the scientist, protect the plane, bomb things, or mixed combat. Two different worldspaces give different experiences, with most Allied missions set in the fjords of Scandinavia and Axis missions correspondingly served in a desert setting. These missions are designed to allow the user to get immersed quickly into them and begin the process of aerial combat.

Adversaries are not as much smart as they are persistent and accurate, which makes them ideal sparring partners, and the addition of anti-aircraft batteries adds layers to the quick mental plans a pilot makes before a run. There are two characters that are arguably level bosses, in the difficult Axis mission five and the surprisingly easy "secret mission," which is mainly an endurance test. Bombing targets and aiming machine guns is intuitive and addicting.

What is most exciting about the game is how easy it is to maneuver like a professional pilot, but how useless that in itself is because your adversaries are equally empowered. Therefore one quickly learns to take on multiple adversaries and outmaneuver them, catapulting gameplay into the realm of dogfighting, which has been the eternal allure of the simpler days of biplanes and machine guns. Tactical supremacy and an ability to choose targets strategically becomes important here.

The game itself is not perfect; it requires a good video card and a fair amount of processing power, but it is delightful to be able to quickly leap into a game and take on opponents without wading through plot contrivances or setting dials. Some glitches annoy; players get turned back at the outer edges of each level, but enemies can and do take advantage of their ability to do so. Sometimes the game drops to a crawl, which makes the plane unstable; maneuvering is less than exact with mouse or keyboard and sometimes fine corrections cause instability as well. Otherwise, it's very tightly engineered, and it rarely crashes.

My suggestion for these developers, on their next version, is to make the three demo missions into the "easy" level and to focus on making the harder missions incorporate more than one strategy (evade detection, attack group, etc) per mission. It would be nice also to see some American planes so everyone sick of the Americans can shoot them down (this probably includes most Americans, as self-loathing is a national pasttime). Something that might also be fun would be an "instant play" option, where one could get dropped into a randomized setting with no mission other than patrol, dogfight, kill and avoid being killed. That sort of thing is best for us covert game players whose fun begins when the boss gets on the phone.

A tiny studio, Small Rockets, has taken the lead with this game and is now countered by several larger software groups attempting to intrude on this territory. It's all well and good that competition produce the best game possible, but for now, this game dominates in terms of playability and all-around fun. Where other games either feel unstable with mouse control or are complex in unnecessary ways that make tedium part of the play experience, this one is pure action and makes you almost feel like a point-n-click Red Ace.

Fun, sort of frustrating

3 Rating: 3, Useful: 5 / 6
Date: November 20, 2002
Author: Amazon User

I haven't played very many flight sims, and I have never played a WWI flight sim, so I don't have much perspective on this game. However, the whole family has found it to be a pretty entertaining game to play.

So why only 3 stars? First of all, it is mighty challenging, sometimes to a ridiculous degree. The game allows you only to play pre-defined missions, with specific objectives. If you simply want to go out and mix it up with the Red Baron, and see how long you can last before you get blasted out of the sky, you are out of luck. The game has no option for that. Also, achieving the objectives may take you dozens of tries. The three training missions, which are supposed to help you get the hang of managing your planes, took me 2 days to get through successfully. That seems to be a bit much, and the regular missions are even more difficult. The game will not allow you to go on to the next mission until you have successfully completed the previous mission, so if you can't get past the early missions, you will never see what else the game has to offer.

Also, I have found that if you play the game for more than an hour, the game will begin to freeze while your plane is engaged. It may be only for a second, but when you are engaged in combat near the ground and have to pull up from your dive at the last second, for example, that freeze will leave your plane exploded into pieces. When this happens, we have to shut the game down for a few minutes, and sometimes re-start the computer. This is annoying.

Decent graphics, entertaining music, easy to handle controls make it a fun game. I am guessing that there are other flight sim games out there that would overshadow this game by quite a bit.

Red Ace Squadron

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 2 / 3
Date: November 20, 2002
Author: Amazon User

I'm an old fan of previous red baron-type PC games. This one is the best yet. I have no tech problems. The graphcs are wonderful and the plane handles like any flight sim on the market. This game is recommended.

A game for sim-lovers who want to dogfight now - not later.

4 Rating: 4, Useful: 1 / 2
Date: August 22, 2004
Author: Amazon User

I very much enjoy this game. As computer-sims go it's a Model-T - the graphics are not spectacular, there are no bells and whistles - such as function knobs or other 'real' real features, and no multiplayer abilities.

But the gameplay is excellent and it's very difficult - until you learn how to make it work. Then it's just a kick-ass turkey-shoot. There are 20 missions. The first set has a less agressive AI engine guiding the opposing planes. The later set, called the 'master level' is slightly more difficult. The real challenge is dogfighting against 3+ planes at a time.

Towards the end of each set there are also more attacking planes and (Aughh!) more anti-aircraft guns all over the place. You either have to bomb them or they'll shoot you up and deny you the ability to pass nearby.

As a mid-price/discount game this is an excellent value that will not dissapoint. You will waste hours with this thing. The music and engine noises make it totally engrossing. You'll be disoriented by the 3D gameplay and thrilled when you pass some of the later levels. I still haven't passed the last one..I'm working on it.

For those who like faster dogfights with more WWII-style planes, check out Crimson Skies, set in the 30's, sort of. It has a better flight engine and other features. It's also a $10 special - more than worth the $$.

RED ACE SQUADRON

1 Rating: 1, Useful: 2 / 11
Date: October 25, 2002
Author: Amazon User

HAVE A HP 510C COMPUTER'\,256 RAM,1.3 INTEL CELERON 40,O GB HARD DRIVE,AND THIS GAME WOULD NOT LOAD PROPERLY .THEIR TECH DEPT WAS OF NO HELP WHATSOEVER,SAYING I PROBABLY NEEDED UPGRADED DRIVERS,WHICH SOUNDS LIKE CAMEL DUNG UNTO ME.SINCE THE OTHER GAMES I HAVE PURCHASED,HAVE ALWAYS LOADED OKAY.MU ADVICE IS BEWARE OF THIS PRODUCT.THERE IS SOMETHING DRASTICALLY WRONG.

Review Page: 1 

Actions