| Unlockable: | How to Unlock: |
| 3-Game Streak (20 Pts) | Go on a 3-game winning streak online. |
| 5 Hit Game (50 Pts) | Have a player get 5 base hits in one game. |
| 5-Game Streak (30 Pts) | Go on a 5-game winning streak online. |
| Closing Time (10 Pts) | Have a pitcher record a "save" by coming into a close ballgame to finish off a win. |
| Cy Young Winner (30 Pts) | During a season, franchise, or GM Career, have a player win the Cy Young award. |
| Double Steal (20 Pts) | Make a successful double steal (2 players steal a base on the same play) |
| Get Connected (20 Pts) | Play a full 9 inning game versus an online opponent |
| Home Run Leader (30 Pts) | During a season, franchise, or GM Career, have a player lead the league in HRs. |
| Join Up (10 Pts) | Join an online league or tournament. |
| League Participation (20 Pts) | Play at least one game in an online league or tournament. |
| Moonshot! (20 Pts) | Hit a mammoth 450+ foot home run. |
| Offensive Explosion (40 Pts) | Score 20 runs in one game on "Pro" or higher difficulty setting. |
| Organized Crime (40 Pts) | Have your team successfully steal 6 bases in one game. |
| Payoff (30 Pts) | Make 10 successful "Payoff Pitches" in one game. |
| Robbery! (20 Pts) | Make a wall climb catch (rob a home run.) |
| Strikeout Leader (30 Pts) | During a season, franchise, or GM Career, have a pitcher lead his league in strikeouts. |
| Strikeout the Side (20 Pts) | Strike out all 3 batters you face in an inning. |
| Super Slugger (30 Pts) | Hit 3 home runs in one game with the same player on "Pro" or higher difficulty setting. |
| Thief (10 Pts) | Successfully steal 2 bases in a game with one player. |
| Triple Double (30 Pts) | Turned 3 double plays in one game. "Triple Double" done baseball style. |
| Trivia Time (5 Pts) | Successfully answer a trivia question between innings of a ball game. |
| Unhittable (50 Pts) | Strikeout 15 batters with one pitcher on "Pro" or higher difficulty setting. |
| Win 10 Online (10 Pts) | Win ten 9 inning games online. |
| Win 20 Online (20 Pts) | Win twenty 9 inning games online. |
| World Series Winner (75 Pts) | Play through a season (offline) and win the World Series. |