| Unlockable | How to Unlock |
| Madden Gamer Level 2 (10) | Reach a Madden Gamer Level of 2. |
| Madden Gamer Level 10 (20) | Reach a Madden Gamer Level of 10. |
| Madden Gamer Level 20 (40) | Reach a Madden Gamer Level of 20. |
| Madden Gamer Level 30 (70) | Reach a Madden Gamer Level of 30. |
| Madden Gamer Level 40 (85) | Reach a Madden Gamer Level of 40. |
| Madden Gamer Level 50 (100) | Reach a Madden Gamer Level of 50. |
| Season Record - Receive TD (20) | Set the season record for Receiving Touchdowns. |
| Season Record - Receiving Yards (20) | Set the season record for Receiving Yards. |
| Season Record - Receptions (20) | Set the season record for Receptions. |
| Season Record - Rush Touchdowns (20) | Set the season record for Rushing Touchdowns. |
| Season Record - Rush Yards (20) | Set the season record for Rushing Yards. |
| Season Record - Pass Yards (20) | Set the season record for Pass Yards. |
| Season Record - Pass TD (20) | Set the season record for Passing Touchdowns. |
| Season Record - Sacks (20) | Set the season record for Sacks. |
| Season Record - INT's (20) | Set the season record for Interceptions. |
| Game Record - Interceptions (10) | Set the single game record for Interceptions. |
| Game Record - Sacks (10) | Set the single game record for Sacks. |
| Game Record - Pass Yards (10) | Set the single game record for Passing Yards. |
| Game Record - Pass Touchdowns (10) | Set the single game record for Passing Touchdowns. |
| Game Record - Rushing Yards (10) | Set the single game record for Rushing Yards. |
| Game Record - Rush TD's (10) | Set the single game record for Rushing Touchdowns. |
| SS Career - 25 Interceptions (20) | SS Career - 25 Interceptions. |
| SS Career - 20 Forced Fumbles (20) | SS Career - 20 Forced Fumbles. |
| SS Career - 100 Sacks (20) | SS Career - 100 Sacks. |
| SS Career - 500 Tackles (20) | SS Career - 500 Tackles. |
| Game Record - Receptions (10) | Set the single game record for Receptions |
| Game Record - Receiving Yards (10) | Set the single game record for Receiving Yards. |
| Game Record - Receiving TD's (10) | Set the single game record for Receiving Touchdowns. |
| All-Madden Shut Out (10) | Pitch a shut out on All-Madden difficulty. |
| 30 Years of Franchise (100) | Complete 30 years of Franchise mode. |
| Perfect Season (30) | Successfully complete a Perfect Season. |
| Super Bowl Win (30) | Win the Super Bowl. |
| Import Draft Class (10) | Successfully import a Draft Class. |
| Mini-Games (5) | Enter the Mini-Games mode. |
| Create-A-Player (5) | Successfully create a player. |
| Live Opponent (5) | Play a Live Opponent game. |
| SS Season - 30 Pass TDs (10) | SS Season - 30 Pass TDs. |
| SS Season - 10 Receiving TDs (10) | SS Season - 10 Receiving TDs. |
| SS Season - 1400 Rush Yards (10) | SS Season - 1400 Rush Yards. |
| SS Season - 140 Tackles (10) | SS Season - 140 Tackles. |
| SS Season - 16 Sacks (10) | SS Season - 16 Sacks. |
| SS Season - 7 Force Fumb (10) | SS Season - 7 Force Fumb. |
| SS Season - 7 INTs (10) | SS Season - 7 INTs. |
| SS Career - 200 Pass TD's (20) | SS Career - 200 Pass TD's. |
| SS Career - 60 Receiving TDs (20) | SS Career - 60 Receiving TDs. |
| SS Career - 10000 Rush Yards (20) | SS Career - 10000 Rush Yards. |