Below are user reviews of Doom 3 and on the right are links to professionally written reviews.
The summary of review scores shows the distribution of scores given by the professional reviewers for Doom 3.
Column height indicates the number of reviews with a score within the range shown at the bottom of the column.
Higher scores (columns further towards the right) are better.
User Reviews (1 - 11 of 18)
Show these reviews first:
Smells like poo, tastes like chicken
5
Rating: 5,
Useful: 3 / 7
Date: January 04, 2007
Author: Amazon User
It's a very good game with a lot of sneaky surprises and scary death aliens. The concept is very original, and it is a very good product. Plus, when you take the DVD out of the case, you can then use the box to fix a wobbly table.
Marine, I Can't Believe You're Still Alive!
5
Rating: 5,
Useful: 2 / 2
Date: October 29, 2006
Author: Amazon User
And neither could I. I got the video game bug recently and so I set out to play some of my old favorites, as I usually prefer classics to the overly complicated new video games. So I started playing DOOM because it is rather quick to play and you can play for small periods of time without getting too sucked in. However, then I heard that during all the years of ignoring video games a new game in the DOOM series, DOOM 3, had been released. So, I got this and became completely engrossed! For the next several days it was just hours and hours and hours of non-stop, terrifying action. They've perfected something that I enjoyed about the Resident Evil series, which was that sense of terror that builds as lights go out or you hear guttural noises behind you, etc. If played in the dark, it is easy to get a little spooked! I liked that you're given a flashlight, I think this not only provided for better game play, but also enhanced the scariness, because you can't attack with your flashlight out, but without it, sometimes you can't see where the enemies are, so you're constantly switching between them. At first I was disappointed that there wasn't automatic vertical targeting, as I was playing this on my laptop and not a controller; but, I finally got to where I was able to fire and aim rather successfully. The story line is a sort-of reworking of the original DOOM story, but way more in-depth. I liked how this seemingly normal mission that you set out on just keeps spiraling and spiraling bigger and bigger. The monsters just keep getting tougher and tougher, and something I liked about this that the old games never had was that you need to use certain weapons to defeat certain enemies more easily. In the old games, I just always used what I had, and maybe saved some big stuff for episode ending bosses. However, in this game, there is more strategy in spray patterns, fire rate, etc. and the speed/size/strength of the enemy you're taking on. Also, the addition of the PDA was a nice touch, allowing you to delve deeper into characters and search for clues. So, check this one out, pretty great game!
Good, but Dark
4
Rating: 4,
Useful: 0 / 1
Date: July 13, 2006
Author: Amazon User
The graphics of the game are awesome, but I find myself using the flashlight tool much too often for my liking. If the game was a bit brighter (not by changing your screen settings), the game would be 5 stars!
Light years ahead of the other first person shooters!!!
5
Rating: 5,
Useful: 1 / 1
Date: January 15, 2006
Author: Amazon User
I finished playing Doom 3 a couple days ago. All I can say is wow.
Anybody who has anything negative to say about this game, is probably somebody who is allergic to things being perfect, and always finds something bad to say about whatever they're judging.
The main complaint about this game is that theres too much time being spent inside dark hallways, and that people want to fight out on the martian surface. But it's perfect as it is. It works in the storyline. It would be hard for me to believe that somebody actually got bored while fighting inside all those "dark hallways".
I'm playing the game on a Dual 1.25Ghz G4 Tower, ATI Radeon 9000/64mb Vram. I play it on Low Quality/800x600 resolution. It looks great!
If you're looking for a game that takes you for hours upon hours through an intense horrifying cinematic gaming experience, and an interesting storyline, BUY THIS GAME.
One more thing I have to say is...
The ending to this game is so amazing, I would have played through the rest of the game 10 times over, to be able to play the ending once. It's the exact opposite of an anti-climactic game. There is no way anyone would be displeased with the ending. It's SO satistying. It's so perfect. It couldn't have been done differently.
Overall this is by far the best game I have ever played. I enjoy playing Call of Duty, Knights of the Old Republic, Return of the King etc, but no game ever created comes close to Doom 3 in any aspect.
This game is a masterpiece.
Review for the Alaska and Military Members Apple User Group
5
Rating: 5,
Useful: 15 / 15
Date: December 03, 2005
Author: Amazon User
In 1994 I played a seminal piece of shareware that did something no game before had. It scared the heebie-jeebies out of me! The game was, of course, Doom. I remember backing up against walls only to hear the unearthly growl of a monster on the other side that sent a shiver up my spine. Fast-forward ten years and iD Software is doing it again!
Despite the number in the title, Doom 3 is really a reinterpretation of the original. Under the much-touted graphical improvements is a serious fleshing-out of the story. In short, the Union Aerospace Corporation's (UAC) research outpost on Mars mistakenly opens a gateway to Hell during a teleportation experiment and a single Marine is left to repel a demonic invasion.
Though embracing spiritual elements, iD has created a plausible future world with sufficient detail to maintain a suspension of disbelief once you're immersed in the game. The story is worthy of attention but even more interesting are the variety of well-implemented devices used to carry it.
In addition to conventional cut-scenes, supplemental plot information can be picked up by overhearing the conversations of non-player characters and by using an in-game personal digital assistant. On the PDA you can watch videos that describe facilities and weapons, read the emails of UAC employees, and listen to well-acted audio logs that explain the decline of Mars City.
Since those plot layers are optional, the story unfolds only as far as the player desires, allowing gamers to adjust the balance between story and action to their liking.
Obviously the graphics are great. The system requirements are high, but they make Doom 3 the unmatched visual leader on the Mac. Under those good looks is fairly traditional first-person gameplay with a large arsenal of familiar Doom weapons, lots of running and shooting, and some clever (yet easy) puzzles.
One way that Doom stands out is interaction with the environment. Mars City is full of interactive computer displays that are accessed without leaving the first-person game view as touch-screens, keeping the player immersed in the world. Such displays are common and used to access supply lockers, control equipment, and download data to the PDA.
It's the superb emphasis on suspense and horror that really makes the game fun though. If played in the dark, with the volume up, there is no reason this game shouldn't make you jump a few times.
Critical to the atmosphere of fear is the combination of eerie sound effects, purposeful lighting, and great cinematic timing. All this wizardry is so essential that the gameplay is molded around it. For example, you aren't allowed to hold your flashlight and a weapon at the same time. You have to choose between lighting your way or keeping your guard up with no idea what might lie ahead.
Unfortunately those elements don't make the multiplayer games special because everything boils down to a Quake-like run, jump, shoot scenario. Online play is also less forgiving of a system on the low end of the requirements. Still, the maps are beautifully derived from the solo campaign, some elements (such as light switches) are still interactive, and the in-game menus are both accessible and useful - a welcome improvement over games that use a text-based console for things like voting.
When played properly and alone, this game is a thrilling ride and a nice contrast to plotless shoot 'em ups. Doom 3 distills the best parts of a haunted house, a horror film, and a shooting gallery into a single satisfying package.
If you want a scarier story than what's been in the theaters lately or if you're a serious gamer, Doom 3 is well worth it. Anyone else who meets the system requirements should at least download the demo.
woot
4
Rating: 4,
Useful: 1 / 1
Date: October 26, 2005
Author: Amazon User
I don't actually own the mac version of this game but i do own and have beaten the PC version almost 3 times. I have, however, downloaded the new mac demo which runs pretty well on all low at my base line ibook G4 1.25 GHz with 256 mb of ram ati radeon mobility 9200 32 mb Vram. For the majority of the time, i get around 10 fps for the first 5 minutes or so and then it just seems to speed up. Some areas, I actually get about 45 fps which is pretty amazing. So anyways, i bought a 1 gb ram upgrade which, i hope, will allow me to play the game on low at 1024x768 with like 40 fps or so. What might have helped the most is that i downloaded the ATI radeon drivers for the mac version of my 9200
from the ati website. If you want to play this game on high or something, don't even try it becasue not only will you get bad performance, but the program automatically turns on like an ultimate pixel shader needing thing that will make the game look like crap on a 9200. I remember the pistol was all chromed almost like pure silver and the faces were two toned: they were half the light tone and half the dark tone.
in terms of gameplay overall from playing the PC version, the game scares you quite a bit if you play it for the first time for the first couple hours of gameplay and then here and there later on. When i played the mac version, i tried to remember everything but of course i failed and i was still scared a few times. Not the most insane fps but a pretty good game in terms of horror
Spooky, scary, and fun FPS that fans of the series will love.
4
Rating: 4,
Useful: 4 / 4
Date: September 25, 2005
Author: Amazon User
Despite the suggestion by another reviewer (whose "review" seems more like an ad for how great his computer is as he doesn't reveal his opinion of the game) that I shouldn't bother wasting anybody's time by reviewing the game because I'm running it on an older system, here goes:
I played the game on a dual 1.25 GHz G4 Power Mac with 1.25 GB of RAM and the new Radeon 9600 Pro with 256 MB VRAM. I got the best performance setting up the game to run 640x480 with bump mapping set to ON, FSAA at 2x, and all other advanced features set to OFF. The frame rate wasn't spectacular, but it was acceptable. Given the low resolution and lack of visual enhancements, I was seriously surprised to see how good the game looked. Obviously, the game will be much better on a G5 with one of the new graphics cards, but fans with older and less powerful systems can still play and have the game look good. If you can get away with it at all, make sure you turn the bump mapping on. It makes a huge difference in how realistic people and creatures look.
The game itself is a lot of fun. The environment and the slightly hokey aspect that keeps you from being able to use your flashlight and a weapon at the same time keep the game scary and enjoyable. The use of the PDA to offer hints and access to new areas is a cool idea, similar to the system used in Metroid Prime for the GameCube. Gameplay will be pretty familiar for fans of the series. Although a remarkable technical achievement, Doom 3 doesn't offer much more than the last two installments in terms of game mechanics: shooting zombies and demons in tight, dark, spooky places is still the order of the day.
This is a great FPS that fans of the series will love. If you have a dual processor G5 with an X800 graphics card to play this game, I envy you. But if you have a reasonable G4 system, you should be able to join in the fun, too. I sure did.
Good, I assume
4
Rating: 4,
Useful: 4 / 4
Date: July 28, 2005
Author: Amazon User
Doom 3 is one of the most intense, scary, gory, horrific first-person-shooters in existence. It wastes no time getting right into the action and substantial, though not deep, plot. However, a good 65% of the way through the overall game, a glitch occured, apparently disabling me from making any more progress through the game. I stepped onto an elevator and pressed the up button. The elevator went up about a foot and stopped, even though the only walkthrough in existence clearly states that it is supposed to continue onto the next level. Despite this flaw disabling me from competing the game, I did thoroughly enjoy what I did get to play. I strongly recommend this game.
not a game you want to play on the mac
2
Rating: 2,
Useful: 4 / 10
Date: July 23, 2005
Author: Amazon User
I personally have decided to switch to the Mac from th PC to save space. I got rid of My Pc network and just have an Imac 20" 2.0Ghz, a 1.25 ghz mac mini, and I still keep my homebuilt PC around for when I need it. I have tried playing this game both on the mac mini an the imac G5. First I would like to mention I don't know how people got good performance on the mac mini, or let me refrase that, got this game to work at all on the mac mini ! You cannot play this game on the Mac Mini I tried, there is no way. People who say this game plays well on the mac mini are smoking something. This game does not even play that well on my new G5 2.0ghz imac ! My homebuilt 3.0ghz plays this game about twice as fast as the imac does. I still had my old 1.7ghz celeron processor that I used before I upgraded my pc to 3.0ghz laying around on my desk. So for kicks I decided to put in the 1.7ghz celeron back into my pc. Even with the slower 1.7ghz celeron the pc is about twice as fast as the imac even when it is clocked 300mhz slower ! Both systems have a 128mb video card. The pc has a 128mb Geforce 6600 GT Extreme and the Imac has a 128 mb Radeon 9600. If you plan on getting decent performance out of this game at ultra high resolutions and maximum detail settings I suggest you play this game on a dual G5 power mac.
I am not impressed at all with doom 3. My main purpose of doom 3 like the quake serious is for benchmarking purposes only. I found the game boring, unorigonal, lighting was to dark. I know its suppose to be dark, but come on it shouldn't be to the extent it ruins the game. All this game is about is shooting monsters up. Traveling in a linear fashion from scene to scene. Players kill all the monsters in one rom and then moving on to the next till they all have been destroyed. What a silly game. The only reason this game gets such godly reviews is because the graphics are supposedly the best, however I thought EQ 2 had a lot better graphics just my opinion. So I would recommend this game to anyone who just cares about graphics and little about the actual game.
Spooky Perfection?
5
Rating: 5,
Useful: 1 / 1
Date: June 12, 2005
Author: Amazon User
an FPS game with atmosphere? no it can't be....yes...yes it is!
for those of us who like games with a bit more than "RUN RUN KILL KILL" then this is definitely an investment. Plays "fine" on lower specs, though the usual Gamers will spit on you if you admit on playing it on a 64 card. But we'll just keep it a secret from them. :)
I used to be terrified of the NES version of Friday the 13th....
You can imagine how playing Doom3 is for me.
Review Page:
1 2 Next
Actions