Below are user reviews of Final Fantasy I & II : Dawn of Souls and on the right are links to professionally written reviews.
The summary of review scores shows the distribution of scores given by the professional reviewers for Final Fantasy I & II : Dawn of Souls.
Column height indicates the number of reviews with a score within the range shown at the bottom of the column.
Higher scores (columns further towards the right) are better.
Summary of Review Scores |
| | | | | | | | | |
0's | 10's | 20's | 30's | 40's | 50's | 60's | 70's | 80's | 90's |
User Reviews (1 - 11 of 55)
Show these reviews first:
Final Fantasy I and II for Gameboy...5/5
5
Rating: 5,
Useful: 49 / 58
Date: November 14, 2004
Author: Amazon User
If you know Final Fantasy I and II, this new release doesn't need much explanation because it is exactly what you remember from the old NES days. The only changes are graphics and sound that aren't that greatly improved. These two games are classics. Final Fantasy I is still great to play, but is a lot easier now. Final Fantasy II was the first FF to feature a complex story with real character development and proves to be a strangely entertaining and fun experience. Even if you haven't played FF, you should still get this game if you have a gameboy; because this game will provide the staying value that your old pokemon games and pinball will not. Oh, and it has few new dungeons that will be a nice suprise ... BUY THIS GAME
Two classic RPGs are reborn!
4
Rating: 4,
Useful: 147 / 158
Date: November 27, 2004
Author: Amazon User
Final Fantasy I & II: Dawn Of Souls (2004.)
In the glory days of the NES, there were two major RPG series that reigned supreme on the system - Enix's Dragon Warrior and Squaresoft's Final Fantasy. The latter series clearly has come out the fan favorite over the years. And in 2004, Squaresoft decided to do gamers a real favor, and rerelease the first two games in the series on the Game Boy Advance! Read on for my review of Dawn Of Souls.
PROS:
-YOU GET TWO CLASSIC RPGS FOR ONE LOW PRICE. These are excellent games, and either one is worth the price of admission alone. Once you start playing these games, you'll see how they earned their classic reputation.
-FINAL FANTASY II IS FINALLY AVAILABLE IN AMERICA ON A NINTENDO SYSTEM! This game had never been released in America before on a Nintendo system, so it's great to finally have it on one - especially a portable one!
-TONS OF BONUS MATERIAL! You don't just get the games here. You also get bonus stuff. If you played the Playstation reissue, you may be familiar with some of it already. The game (FF1) even includes bonus dungeons where you can battle bosses from other FF games!
-FF1 IS EASY TO LEARN. Unlike other RPGs, which take a LONG time to learn, you can pick the first installment up pretty fast.
-SAVE ANYWHERE! This is a great convenience. Not even the DS version of Final Fantasy III included this option, making your life much easier.
-IMPROVED GRAPHICS AND SOUND. This game is based on the Wonderswam Color port that was never released stateside, and as such, definitely looks better than the NES releases.
CONS:
-THESE GAMES ARE VERY SIMPLISTIC BY MODERN STANDARDS. More likely than not, die-hard RPG fans aren't going to give this package the respect it deserves. Sometimes simplicity is a package's greatest strength, but some people just don't get that.
-FINAL FANTASY I DOESN'T HAVE MUCH OF A STORYLINE AT ALL. Essentially, you pick four characters - and they have no background story whatsoever. A highly-involved storyline is one of the best parts of later FF games - too bad the first installment doesn't have that. And you can't change their classes, either. What they start as, they're stuck as.
-FF2 IS WEIRD, AND IT'S NOT GONNA APPEAL TO EVERYONE. There is no standard "level up" system in this game, instead you level up attributes of your character a number of different ways in a battle. Thank god this was the only game in the series to use this system. The weird "key word" system doesn't help things either.
-SOME BONUSES MISSING THAT WERE ON THE PLAYSTATION REISSUE. NOT a big deal, and this was to be expected given the PS is a stronger system. Still worth mentioning though.
OVERALL:
Overall these are very good classic RPGs. I just wish these old-school games got more credit than they do, because in their day and age, they were truly revolutionary. If you're a GBA owner and a classic RPG fan, don't hesitate to purchase this package.
Fun
5
Rating: 5,
Useful: 7 / 9
Date: November 30, 2004
Author: Amazon User
This was definitly one of the most interesting games I have ever seen. This game has nearly done the unbelieveable. This game has taken 2 old school games, merged them into one, then improved it with upgraded battle systems and better graphics. Like I said Unbelievable.
Just like the old days!
5
Rating: 5,
Useful: 4 / 8
Date: December 02, 2004
Author: Amazon User
I love this game! I remember the days of playing FF2 and 3 for the SNES and this game is just like that! The graphics are great, the sound is great and the story lines are cool!
I support this game... it brings back good memories of my child hood.
If you liked Final Fantasy II, Watch Out!
4
Rating: 4,
Useful: 12 / 17
Date: December 05, 2004
Author: Amazon User
This is a cleaned up version on Final Fantasy I, for the GBA. Mostly everything you loved from the original RPG that started it all is here, with improved graphics and sound. Even the original's impressive music is enhanced, not changed. HOWEVER, if you buy this game hoping to get Final Fantasy II, the adventure of Cecil the Dark Knight of Baron, you'll be disappointed. USA's Final Fantasy II (for the SNES) was released in Japan as Final Fantasy IV! This game pack does not include that game! Which is unfortunate, as it remains a masterpiece. Instead, you'll get a translated version of Japan's Final Fantasy II, which is very dissapointing in comparison, though a fine game in and of itself. In short, if you LOVED FF I, buy this game for hours of fun on your Game Boy Advanced. Who knows, you'll probably like FF II. But if you want FF IV (USA - FF II), either call Sqare Enix (the game developer), or dust off your old Super Nintendo.
Dramatically easier than the original
4
Rating: 4,
Useful: 12 / 16
Date: December 06, 2004
Author: Amazon User
If you're a purist (which I'm not) you'll probably be irritated by how much easier the game is than the original (I'm referring to FF1 here, haven't played the second one yet). Here's a breakdown of the changes as far as I'm aware of them:
1.) Leveling up is much faster. Stats increase at a greater rate per level. Also, the maximum level has been raised from 50 to 99.
2.) You can save everywhere, at any time, not just at Inns or with the tent or whatever.
3.) The magic system has been altered so that instead of certain spells having a fixed number of uses, they have a casting cost that is deducted from your character's MP.
4.) There are a couple of new potions that make things a lot easier, namely Phoenix Down and Ether, the former reviving a dead character and the latter restoring MP. These make it pretty unnecessary to truck back to town frequently to go to the church or inn.
That said, it doesn't bother me that much, as I don't have the patience for old-school style RPGs. Remember what a nightmare Dragon Warrior was? Overall I like the changes, but I think they went a little too far. If they'd left out just one of the new "enhancements" I think enough of the challenge would still be there. 3.5 stars.
Final Fantasy Dawns with its first two games
5
Rating: 5,
Useful: 3 / 3
Date: December 21, 2004
Author: Amazon User
Final Fantasy is a legendary series. It seems that with "Dawn of Souls" Final Fantasy I and II have finally been perfected. If you have "Final Fantasy Origins" you might as well toss it and pick up this title before it becomes a relic!
Both Final Fantasy games are basically ports of "Final Fantasy Origins" but they look a bit better on the GBA. For starters, the graphics look more crisp and clear than they did in Final Fantasy Origins. There's more to see and the enviroments look more decorative.
Final Fantasy I, the earliest in the series, is about four warriors who come forth with the crystals to save the world. Light warriors, they're called. But being the first in the series it suffers from age. The main characters don't talk much at all and the characters remained undeveloped throughout the entire game.
Final Fantasy II however, is about three orphans escaping the Emperor. They later join a rebellion against the Emperor and set out to take him down once and for all. Final Fantasy II has a twist when raising characters. Rather than raising character based on level-ups, they're raised based on their actions in battle. This is both good and bad. It's good because its "different" than what we usually see. It's bad because when stats go up, others go down. It's impossible to have a perfectly balanced character. That and magic will almost never amount to anything.
Both games sound beautiful from the GBA. Many gamers will recognize their favorite tunes. The sound effects are a little changed up from the original NES titles. But I'm sure that's nothing to go crying home to mom about.
Also, both games have a set of extras. In Final Fantasy I after you defeat the four fiends of chaos, four optional dungeons open up. These dungeons are brutally hard. You'll also run into enemies seen in later Final Fantasy games. You'll even run into a few bosses that'll look familiar. Final Fantasy II, presents an extended epilogue. Unfortunately FFII doesn't present much more than that.
However, the problem is... both games still suffer from their drawbacks. Final Fantasy I paces much too slowly and you'll often times feel bored or robbed of your money. Final Fantasy DOES pick up the pace and you'll be glad you did spend you cash on it. Final Fantasy has also been toned down in its aspects of difficulty.
Final Fantasy II's level up system still has bugs that just don't work out well. Unless you subject to attacking your own characters you won't benefit from their actions. Final Fantasy II also doesn't tell as good of a story, even with the new extended scenes to better explain it.
As a whole the games are excellent. But there's also the problem of whether or not you already own Final Fantasy Origins. Are the extras worthwhile just to spend more money to buy two games that are virtually the same as "Final Fantasy Origins"?
However, putting that last con aside, the GBA is where these two classics belong and is where they should've gone in the first place. So I say this: Dump your Final Fantasy Origins and pick up Final Fantasy Dawn of Souls. It's much more worthwhile and worth the money.
The Good
+Delicious graphics!
+Great sound
+Remake of two classics: They're PERFECT this time
+Extras... not many but extras!
+Most of the bugs from the NES and Origins packages are worked out
The Bad
-Final Fantasy I still paces too slow
-The level up system in Final Fantasy II still needs work
-If you have Final Fantasy Origins you'll ponder whether the extras alone make it worthwhile to buy virtually the same game.
Just like I remember it...
5
Rating: 5,
Useful: 9 / 9
Date: December 23, 2004
Author: Amazon User
Last year saw the release of Final Fantasy Origins on PSOne. A compilation pack of the first two Final Fantasy titles, the second of which had been previously unavailable in America, Origins gave gamers the chance to play through the first two entries in the series with a new coat of paint. Featuring updated graphics, full motion video cutscenes, several optional gameplay tweaks and more, Origins carefully walked the fine line of pleasing both veterans and newcomers to the games. With Dawn of Souls, Square continues to refine the old classics.
As with Origins, the versions of Final Fantasy 1 & 2 present in Dawn of Souls are based off the Japan-only WonderSwan Color remakes. This time around, the scripts were re-written and numerous additions and tweaks to the games themselves were made. Most noteworthy of these changes is the ability to save anywhere outside of battle, an important feature in a handheld RPG.The focus of Final Fantasy 1 is less on the story and more on exploration and fighting. Those that have played prior versions will note that the GBA edition is more balanced in that it doesn't require players to stop and level up their characters to survive the next dungeon, resulting in a much more streamlined experience. The flipside is that the revamped FF1 ends up lacking the challenge of past iterations, a virtual cakewalk for those familiar with the game. The only real challenge is in the form of the four new dungeons. These randomly generated dungeons, which feature bosses from Final Fantasy 3-6, reward players with rare and powerful items once cleared. With each dungeon unlocked after the defeat of the respective Chaos, some may find themselves questioning if it's even worth the time and effort to reach the new content. Of course, it's this lack of difficulty that makes the title perfect for handheld gaming, as you can fight a few battles, save and then restart where you left off hours, days, weeks or even months later without worrying too much about having to start over. The other major change in FF1 comes in the form of spell use. Previously dependant upon a character's level, magic now utilizes the more popular MP system, helping to make the game more accessible to newcomers. Spells, much like weapons, must be purchased and require a user to be a specific level before they can be equipped.Notorious for its unique leveling system, Final Fantasy 2 has also undergone several alterations. While characters still gain strength as they use an ability, you'll no longer need to rely upon attacking members of your own party to increase their hit points as this aspect has been more carefully balanced. A brand new epilogue, entitled "Soul of Rebirth," has also been added.
Of the two games, Final Fantasy 2 is the more story-driven, with a greater emphasis on character development. The stories seem a little tired and cliched, though that's mostly due to their age and influence on the role-playing genre. Fighting is handled by a traditional turn-based battle system, with random encounters occurring every so often outside of towns.It's also worth noting that Dawn of Souls includes some of the most impressive music on the Game Boy Advance to date, ranking right up there with Castlevania: Circle of the Moon. With two games and a bestiary on the cartridge, it's a testament to Square's prowess that they were also able to accommodate such rich and detailed sound.Though they may lack the depth and complexity of the modern games they inspired, Final Fantasy 1 & 2 are still quite enjoyable, and definitely worth playing if you're a fan of RPGs.
Not What I Thought It Was Going To Be...
1
Rating: 1,
Useful: 0 / 26
Date: December 26, 2004
Author: Amazon User
This game is made out to be a masterpiece but in my opinion the game lacks a good storyline, and REALLY lacks good graphics. The old Pokemon games had better graphics than this game. The graphics seem like they were just thrown together. I dont reccomend this game to anyone, unless you dont care about the graphic quiality, and will be returning mine.
Another New Thought For Final Fantasy....
5
Rating: 5,
Useful: 2 / 4
Date: December 31, 2004
Author: Amazon User
If you have read my review on Final Fantasy Tactics for the GBA the title is similar. Now the first FF game I played was FFT. I thought that the bangaas, moogles, and the other races were FF all the way. I was wrong. My parents are super strict about video games, but I managed to squeeze my GBA in, so that's why I haven't played other FF games. So sorry if this review isn't what you thought it would be.
Like FFT there is the turn taking battle system. It's kinda dull, yet fun at the same time. Get my groove? Anyway the FF 1 is more of a "fun" game. The story line isn't so hot and the characters you play(The Warriors of LIght) never talk. So there isn't a character "build up". The game is still a blast though. Also the game moves a bit slow...well for us experienced GBA gamers * smooths hair back *. Anyway, it's a great game, loads of fun, the improved graphics are pretty cool to, and it's good for beginners.
Now, personally my favorite, FF 2. GOOD story line. Thank god....I hate those other cheesy NIntendo story lines. When a person is talking, by the way the people you play as talk ( Yes!), it shows a face next to the text, the face sometimes makes expressions to! The battle system is the same, the turns. One thing I love is the weapon and magic levels! Each time a skill level increases the weapon does more damage and it's defense raises. For magic it will say"Thunder Lvl. 1" and when you advance a level it will say"Thunder Lvl. 2" and a cooler image of thunder will appear. Pretty sweet, eh? This game is MUCH better than the first, but the first is STILL fun. Don't worry.
These to classics are must buys for FF fans, or RPG fans!
[...]
Review Page:
1 2 3 4 5 6 Next
Actions